HIV Justice

The HIV Justice Network is a global information and advocacy hub for individuals and organisations working to end the inappropriate use of the criminal law to regulate and punish people living with HIV.

  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • RSS
  • Vimeo

Main menu

Skip to primary content
Skip to secondary content
  • Home
  • About
  • News
  • Blog
  • Topics
  • Cases
  • Countries
  • Video
  • Oslo Declaration
  • Advancing HIV Justice 2
England United Kingdom Wales Events Law and policy reform Public health Public health approaches Research Resources Social science

UK: Law Commission scoping consultation deadline this week; key findings and outputs from ‘Criminalizing Contagion’ seminar series may help inform the process

Edwin J Bernard - February 9, 2015
Tweet
Print

This week, the Law Commission – which reviews areas of the law in England and Wales that have become unduly complicated, outdated or unfair –  will conclude its scoping consultation of the reform the Offences Against The Person Act, the law that is currently used to prosecute people living with HIV (and occasionally other sexually transmitted infections; one each so far for gonorrhoea, hepatitis B and genital herpes) for ‘reckless’ or ‘intentional’ transmission, as grievous bodily harm.

The deadline for responses is this Wednesday 11 February 2015.

The consultation is a scoping review – it is looking at the scope of whether a further full review of the existing law should take place, rather than examining what the law should be.

The consultation asks six key questions (out of 38) specifically relating to HIV (and STI) criminalisation:

  1. We consider that future reform of offences against the person should take account of the ramifications of disease transmission.  Do consultees agree?
  2. We also consider that in such reform consideration should be given to:  (1)  whether disease should in principle fall within the definition of injury in any reforming statute that may be based on the draft Bill; (2)  whether, if the transmission of sexual infections through consensual intercourse is to be excluded, this should be done by means of a specific exemption limited to that situation.  This could be considered in a wider review; alternatively (3)  whether the transmission of disease should remain within the offences as in existing law. Do consultees agree?
  3. If the transmission of disease is to be included in any future reform including offences causing injury, it will be necessary to choose between the following possible rules about the disclosure of the risk of infection, namely: (1)  that D should be bound to disclose facts indicating a risk of infection only if the risk is significant; or (2)  that D should be bound to disclose facts indicating a risk of infection in all circumstances; or that whether D was justified in exposing V to that risk without disclosing it should be a question for the jury in each particular case. Do consultees have any preference as to these possible rules?
  4. We consider the reform of offences against the person should consider the extent to which transmission of minor infections would be excluded from the scope of injury offences.  Do consultees agree?
  5. Do consultees consider that future reform should pursue the possibility of including specialized offences of transmission of infection, endangerment or non-disclosure?
  6. Do consultees have observations on the use of ASBOs, SOPOs or other means of penalizing non-disclosure?

Responses to the scoping consultation, including those from the HIV Justice Network, will be published soon. Following the consultation, the Law Commission will decide on their recommendations for the scope of reform in this area and present them to Government in the form of a scoping report.

In the meantime, the summary of key findings and outputs from the Economic and Social Research Council’s seminar series ‘Criminalizing Contagion: legal and ethical challenges of disease transmission and the criminal law’, which took place at the Universities of Southampton and Manchester from January 2012 until September 2014, provides a comprehensive legal and academic overview regarding how the law should treat a person who transmits, or exposes others to the risk of, a serious infection such as HIV.

Written jointly by David Gurnham, Catherine Stanton and Hannah Quirk, the report provides a detailed overview of the discussions in the seminars as well as the numerous publications arising from them, and acknowledges contributions made by various groups and individuals.

From other sources

  • News
  • Cases

US: Health and policy experts talks about efforts to reform HIV laws in Ohio & Indiana

All IN: The HIV Modernization Movement
December 13, 2019

Dominican Republic: National Council for HIV asks for a review of HIV laws & drug laws, including HIV criminalisation provisions

Conavihsida asks to modify the HIV–AIDS law in the country
December 13, 2019

US: Bipartisan group of Missouri Lawmakers working to change HIV Laws that date from the 1980s

Missouri Lawmakers Want To Bring HIV Laws To The 21st Century
December 12, 2019

Human rights are key to ending the epidemics

OPINION: End epidemics by breaking down human rights barriers to health
December 11, 2019

US: It’s time Ohio’s laws reflected our new understanding of the science of HIV

Ohio’s HIV laws should be based on science, not hysteria
December 6, 2019

Jamaica: Proposed amendment to criminalise willful transmission of HIV is unnecessary and already covered under general criminal law

Stakeholders Resist Proposal To Criminalize Willful Transmission Of HIV
December 5, 2019

Kenya: Advocates argue that HIV criminalisation law is impeding progress in Kenya’s response to the epidemic

Group criticises sexual offences law in war against HIV
December 2, 2019

The response to HIV is hampered by repressive legislation and policies

Power to the people: repressive laws hamper grassroots response to HIV, report warns
November 27, 2019

US: Growing number of Ohio public health experts and advocates call for reform of HIV criminalisation law

Experts: Ohio law on HIV status disclosure hurts public health
November 26, 2019

HIV Criminalisation takes centre stage at AIDS Action Europe member and partner Meeting

E–News AIDS Action Europe Member and Partner Meeting 2019
November 20, 2019

US: Sex worker arrested in undercover operation and facing charges of HIV exposure in Georgia

Police: Sex worker didn’t disclose she was HIV status
December 5, 2019

US: Man arrested and charged in Oklahoma for alleged HIV non-disclosure and transmission

Man arrested, accused of knowingly spreading HIV to two people
December 5, 2019

Tajikistan: Criminal proceedings could be instigated against 2 women in the future if sexual partners develop HIV

Two women may have infected dozens of men in Khatlon with HIV, says Khatlon governor
November 30, 2019

[Update]Russia: Prosecutor approves charges against senior nurse in case of negligence leading to HIV transmissions in Budennovsk hospital

Court investigate to determinate responsibility for the infection of five patients with HIV in hospital in Budennovsk
November 29, 2019

US: 40-year-old Tennessee man charged with alleged HIV exposure

Nashville man indicted on HIV exposure charge
November 26, 2019

US: 42-year-old man charged in Wisconsin for alleged HIV exposure and transmission

HIV–positive man charged after sex with 6 women
November 24, 2019

India: Woman lodges police complaint against medical staff of blood bank after contracting HIV during transfusion

Pregnant woman contracts HIV after blood transfusion in Tamil Nadu
November 23, 2019

[Update]France: Court of appeal increases sentence of 63-year-old man to 4 years for alleged HIV transmission

Perpignan: sentence increased to 4 years for having transmitted HIV to his partner
November 23, 2019

[update]US: Previously convicted ex-police officer facing five felony charges for alleged HIV non-disclosure is heading to trial

Trial to start for ex–cop accused of not telling sexual partners he has HIV
November 20, 2019

[Update]France: 47-year-old man sentenced to 4 years in jail for alleged HIV transmission and non-disclosure

Un Loirétain accusé d’avoir délibérément transmis le virus du sida à son épouse
November 20, 2019
View more >

Sign up for the HIV Justice newsletter

Sign up for regular updates

For more information, please see our Privacy policy

 
Privacy and Cookies Policy | Contact Us

We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. By continuing to use our site, you are agreeing to our use of cookies. You can change your cookie settings at any time if you want. Find out more in our privacy and cookie policy

Accept Close