Skip to content
HIV Justice Network
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • YouTube
  • Home
  • About
    • HIV Justice Network
    • Staff and Consultants
    • Supervisory Board
    • Global Advisory Panel
    • Our Policies
    • Our Funders
      • ANBI Status
  • News
    • By the HIV Justice Network
    • Curated from other sources
    • HIV JUSTICE NEWS (Newsletter)
  • Academy
  • Database
    • Overview
    • Laws and Analyses
    • Cases
    • Organisations
    • Disclaimer
  • Publications
  • Video
  • Contact Us
  • Donate
News curated from other sources

US: New study shows that laws criminalising HIV exposure do not cut down on HIV transmission

2 May 2017
Impact Social science Science Public health
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
Source: http://www.huffingtonpost.com/entry/criminal-hiv-transmission_us_59076071e4b05c397680f3cc

Criminalizing HIV Transmission doesn’t cut down on new diagnoses

Penalizing people who don’t disclose their status is bad policy, a new study finds.

More than 30 years since the first criminal laws were enacted in the United States to try to prevent the spread of the human immunodeficiency virus, a new study suggests that the regulations have failed to slow transmission of the deadly virus.

The laws impose criminal penalties on people who know they have HIV and engage in behaviors such as sexual activity or needle sharing that might transmit the virus to others, without disclosing their infection status.

“There has been much discussion about whether criminal-exposure laws affect HIV-risk behaviors or transmission,” senior author Dr. Jonathan Mermin said in an email. “In this analysis, we found no association between HIV diagnosis rates and laws that criminalize HIV exposure.”

Working with data collected in 33 states from 2001-2010, Mermin and colleagues at the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) in Atlanta tracked diagnoses of HIV, the virus that causes the acquired immunodeficiency syndrome (AIDS). They also analyzed AIDS diagnosis rates in all 50 states from 1994-2010.

By the end of 2010, 30 states had passed criminal-exposure laws. But the new study, published in the journal AIDS, found no association between criminal-exposure laws and HIV or AIDS diagnosis rates.

The researchers did find two factors associated with higher HIV and AIDS diagnosis rates: lack of education and living in urban areas.

Ayako Miyashita, director of the Los Angeles HIV Law and Policy Project at the UCLA School of Law, said the study “underscores the fact that we understand the social and structural drivers of the epidemic, and that criminalization is not a particularly useful tool in addressing HIV transmission.”

“These laws are harmful,” said Miyashita, who was not involved with the study, in an email. “They embody the continued fear and stigma associated with HIV and serve to perpetuate a lack of awareness and understanding about existing biomedical interventions.”

More than 1.2 million people in the U.S. have been diagnosed with HIV, according to the CDC. About a third of them take antiretroviral therapy, which can virtually eliminate the possibility of transmitting the virus to others.

Few HIV criminalization laws consider whether an HIV-positive person took measures to reduce the risk of transmitting the virus, the authors write.

A 2013 report in ProPublica pointed out that people have been prosecuted for nondisclosure of HIV infection even when they were using condoms or taking antiviral drugs that made transmission very unlikely (http://bit.ly/1ZBdlfN).

HIV criminal-exposure laws have engendered debate about their effectiveness since 1986, when states first enacted them, the authors write. The laws were intended to encourage people who tested positive for HIV to disclose the fact to potential sex partners and to discourage behaviors that could expose others.

Some feared the laws could have the reverse effect and increase transmission by discouraging testing; if people don’t know they have the virus, they can’t be prosecuted under these laws.

Since 2010, an estimated 40,000 people a year in the U.S. have been diagnosed with HIV.

HIV disproportionately infects blacks, African-Americans, gay Hispanics and Hispanics who inject drugs, previous studies have shown. The new analysis too found that minority populations had higher HIV and AIDS diagnosis rates.

Amira Hasenbush, who has studied HIV criminalization laws in California, said in an email that her research has shown that the laws disproportionately target women and people of color. Hasenbush, a fellow at The Williams Institute at the UCLA School of Law, was not involved with the new study.

“Enforcement data show that HIV criminalization is yet another example of the criminalization of the poor, criminalization of people of color and criminalization of otherwise marginalized populations,” Miyashita said. “We know HIV impacts these communities greatly, and it’s time we realize criminalization is not the solution to addressing the epidemic.”

Miyashita called for review, if not repeal, of all HIV criminalization laws.

“Criminalization is not the solution to this problem,” she said. “These data prove that.”

Published in the Huffpost on May 1, 2017

News curated from other sources

US: Governor signs bill to repeal HIV criminalisation statute in Maryland

Maryland Repeals HIV Criminalization Law
May 21, 2025

[Update]US: STD criminalisation bill withdrawn as advocates call for education and resources

Louisiana lawmakers shelve bill criminalizing ‘intentional exposure’ to STDs
May 11, 2025

USA: Louisiana lawmaker renews push to criminalise STI exposure

Bill revives effort to criminalize non-consensual STD exposure in Louisiana
April 25, 2025

Canada: Canada’s broken promise on HIV criminalisation reform

HIV criminalization and the Canadian government’s failed law reform project: Another. Incredible. Disappointment. Surprise!
April 3, 2025

US: North Dakota Governor signs into law House Bill 1217 to reform outdated HIV criminalisation laws

North Dakota decriminalises State HIV laws
March 28, 2025

News by the HIV Justice Network

Zimbabwe's victory:
A beacon of hope for HIV justice amid global challenges

March 28, 2025

New case study and documentary examines how Zimbabwe repealed its HIV criminalisation law

March 5, 2025

HIV Is Not a Crime Awareness Day:
A Call to Action in a Time of Crisis

February 28, 2025

UK Parliamentary Reception Marks HIV Is Not A Crime Awareness Day

February 28, 2025

HJN's Executive Director's remarks at the UK Parliamentary event commemorating HIV is Not a Crime Awareness Day

February 26, 2025
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • YouTube
Disclaimer

This website operates as a global hub, consolidating a wide range of resources on HIV criminalisation for advocates working to abolish criminal and similar laws, policies and practices that regulate, control and punish people living with HIV based on their HIV-positive status. While we endeavour to ensure that all information is correct and up-to-date, we cannot guarantee the accuracy of laws or cases. The information contained on this site is not a substitute for legal advice. Anyone seeking clarification of the law in particular circumstances should seek legal advice. Read more

Registered office:
Stichting HIV Justice (HIV Justice Foundation), Korte Lijnbannssteeg 1, Kamer 4007, 1012 SL Amsterdam, the Netherlands

You can select your preferred language from the 'Select Language' menu at the top of the page.

Continue

We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. By continuing to use our site, you are agreeing to our use of cookies. You can change your cookie settings at any time if you want. Find out more in our Privacy & Cookie Policy.

Accept Close