Skip to content
HIV Justice Network
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • YouTube
  • Home
  • About
    • HIV Justice Network
    • Team
    • Supervisory Board
    • Global Advisory Panel
    • Disclaimer
    • Contact Us
    • Privacy & Cookies Policy
  • News
    • By the HIV Justice Network
    • Curated from other sources
    • HIV Justice Weekly
  • Global HIV Criminalisation Database
    • Overview
    • Laws and Analyses
    • Cases
    • Organisations
  • Publications
  • Videos
  • Contact Us
News by the HIV Justice Network

UK: Law Commission scoping consultation deadline this week; key findings and outputs from ‘Criminalizing Contagion’ seminar series may help inform the process

9 February 2015
England Wales United Kingdom Law and policy reform Public health approaches Events Resources Social science Research Public health
  • Twitter
  • Facebook

This week, the Law Commission – which reviews areas of the law in England and Wales that have become unduly complicated, outdated or unfair –  will conclude its scoping consultation of the reform the Offences Against The Person Act, the law that is currently used to prosecute people living with HIV (and occasionally other sexually transmitted infections; one each so far for gonorrhoea, hepatitis B and genital herpes) for ‘reckless’ or ‘intentional’ transmission, as grievous bodily harm.

The deadline for responses is this Wednesday 11 February 2015.

The consultation is a scoping review – it is looking at the scope of whether a further full review of the existing law should take place, rather than examining what the law should be.

The consultation asks six key questions (out of 38) specifically relating to HIV (and STI) criminalisation:

  1. We consider that future reform of offences against the person should take account of the ramifications of disease transmission.  Do consultees agree?
  2. We also consider that in such reform consideration should be given to:  (1)  whether disease should in principle fall within the definition of injury in any reforming statute that may be based on the draft Bill; (2)  whether, if the transmission of sexual infections through consensual intercourse is to be excluded, this should be done by means of a specific exemption limited to that situation.  This could be considered in a wider review; alternatively (3)  whether the transmission of disease should remain within the offences as in existing law. Do consultees agree?
  3. If the transmission of disease is to be included in any future reform including offences causing injury, it will be necessary to choose between the following possible rules about the disclosure of the risk of infection, namely: (1)  that D should be bound to disclose facts indicating a risk of infection only if the risk is significant; or (2)  that D should be bound to disclose facts indicating a risk of infection in all circumstances; or that whether D was justified in exposing V to that risk without disclosing it should be a question for the jury in each particular case. Do consultees have any preference as to these possible rules?
  4. We consider the reform of offences against the person should consider the extent to which transmission of minor infections would be excluded from the scope of injury offences.  Do consultees agree?
  5. Do consultees consider that future reform should pursue the possibility of including specialized offences of transmission of infection, endangerment or non-disclosure?
  6. Do consultees have observations on the use of ASBOs, SOPOs or other means of penalizing non-disclosure?

Responses to the scoping consultation, including those from the HIV Justice Network, will be published soon. Following the consultation, the Law Commission will decide on their recommendations for the scope of reform in this area and present them to Government in the form of a scoping report.

In the meantime, the summary of key findings and outputs from the Economic and Social Research Council’s seminar series ‘Criminalizing Contagion: legal and ethical challenges of disease transmission and the criminal law’, which took place at the Universities of Southampton and Manchester from January 2012 until September 2014, provides a comprehensive legal and academic overview regarding how the law should treat a person who transmits, or exposes others to the risk of, a serious infection such as HIV.

Written jointly by David Gurnham, Catherine Stanton and Hannah Quirk, the report provides a detailed overview of the discussions in the seminars as well as the numerous publications arising from them, and acknowledges contributions made by various groups and individuals.

News by the HIV Justice Network

WATCH! From Moment to Movement: HIV Justice Live! Ep 3 - Oslo Declaration 9th Anniversary

February 19, 2021

HIV Justice Live Ep 3: Celebrating 9th Anniversary of the Oslo Declaration

February 12, 2021

It's all about justice and love this Valentines!

February 10, 2021

Welcoming two new members to the HIV Justice Network team

January 22, 2021

Year in review: Celebrating successes, highlighting the many challenges ahead

December 18, 2020

News curated from other sources

Nigeria: Jigawa State adopts law recommending death penalty in cases of rape resulting in HIV transmission

Jigawa Assembly passes law stipulating life sentence for rapist
February 20, 2021

US[Update]: Virginia House of Delegates passes bill to amend HIV criminalisation law

Virginia General Assembly passes bill to modernize HIV laws
February 20, 2021

US: Bipartisan effort to modernize Georgia’s HIV laws

Republican lawmaker wants to modernize Georgia’s HIV laws
February 19, 2021

Australia: New South Wales mandatory testing bill is unnecessary and could be counterproductive

Mandatory disease testing bill ‘could put officers at risk’
February 12, 2021

US: Virginia's bill to reform the state’s infected sexual battery law will also broaden its scope to include all STIs

Lawmakers weigh how far to go in changing a decades-old law criminalizing HIV
February 10, 2021
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • YouTube
Disclaimer

This website operates as a global hub, consolidating a wide range of resources on HIV criminalisation for advocates working to abolish criminal and similar laws, policies and practices that regulate, control and punish people living with HIV based on their HIV-positive status. While we endeavour to ensure that all information is correct and up-to-date, we cannot guarantee the accuracy of laws or cases. The information contained on this site is not a substitute for legal advice. Anyone seeking clarification of the law in particular circumstances should seek legal advice. Read more

Registered office:
Stichting HIV Justice (HIV Justice Foundation), Eerste Helmersstraat 17 B 3, 1054 CX Amsterdam, The Netherlands

The HIV Justice Network is supported by a grant from the Robert Carr Fund provided to the HIV Justice Global Consortium.

The HIV Justice Network is also grateful to The Monument Trust for its generous support between 2012-15.

We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. By continuing to use our site, you are agreeing to our use of cookies. You can change your cookie settings at any time if you want. Find out more in our Privacy & Cookie Policy.

Accept Close