HIV Justice

The HIV Justice Network is a global information and advocacy hub for individuals and organisations working to end the inappropriate use of the criminal law to regulate and punish people living with HIV.

  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • RSS
  • Vimeo

Main menu

Skip to primary content
Skip to secondary content
  • Home
  • About
  • News
  • Blog
  • Topics
  • Cases
  • Countries
  • Video
  • Oslo Declaration
  • Advancing HIV Justice 2
USA Public health Research Resources Social science

Social Science Update: Review of HIV criminalisation research in the US, 1990-2014

Laurel Sprague - November 23, 2016
Tweet
Print

An article reviewing 15 years of U.S.-based social science research on HIV criminalisation was published in the September 2016 issue of AIDS and Behavior. The research team, led by Dini Harsono of Yale University’s Center for Interdisciplinary Research on AIDS (CIRA), Criminalization of HIV Exposure Work Group, described results from twenty-five research studies conducted in the US from 1990-2014. Studies were conducted with women and men living with HIV, gay men and other men who have sex with men (HIV-positive and –negative), public health workers, and medical providers.

Across the studies, the authors found that, while awareness of HIV exposure laws was generally low, attitudes were generally supportive of criminalisation.[1] The studies showed little to no relationship between the existence of laws and decisions to disclose one’s positive HIV status or to test for HIV. The clearest relationships between stigma and HIV non-disclosure laws could be found from the Sero Project study findings that people living with HIV expect to be treated with bias in the courts simply because of their HIV status. The authors call for future studies to pay more attention to health outcomes, rather than attitudes, and to more closely research prosecution and enforcement practices.

For a global overview of HIV criminalisation research, see O’Byrne et al. (2013). “HIV criminal prosecutions and public health: an examination of the empirical research.”

Details

Criminalization of HIV Exposure: A Review of Empirical Studies in the United States, by Dini Harsono, Carol L. Galletly, Elaine O’Keefe, Zita Lazzarini. AIDS Behavior. DOI 10.1007/s10461-016-1540-5. Published online: 7 Sept 2016.

[1] Although the Sero Project study (2012) was included in the research review, one key set of findings was not discussed. In the Sero Project study, support for criminalisation dramatically declined when survey respondents were provided additional response options (beyond only the choice to support criminalization or not) in survey questions.

Criminalization of HIV Exposure: A Review of Empirical Studies in the United States

From other sources

  • News
  • Cases

US: It’s time Ohio’s laws reflected our new understanding of the science of HIV

Ohio’s HIV laws should be based on science, not hysteria
December 6, 2019

Jamaica: Proposed amendment to criminalise willful transmission of HIV is unnecessary and already covered under general criminal law

Stakeholders Resist Proposal To Criminalize Willful Transmission Of HIV
December 5, 2019

Kenya: Advocates argue that HIV criminalisation law is impeding progress in Kenya’s response to the epidemic

Group criticises sexual offences law in war against HIV
December 2, 2019

The response to HIV is hampered by repressive legislation and policies

Power to the people: repressive laws hamper grassroots response to HIV, report warns
November 27, 2019

US: Growing number of Ohio public health experts and advocates call for reform of HIV criminalisation law

Experts: Ohio law on HIV status disclosure hurts public health
November 26, 2019

HIV Criminalisation takes centre stage at AIDS Action Europe member and partner Meeting

E–News AIDS Action Europe Member and Partner Meeting 2019
November 20, 2019

Ireland: Review conducted by Law Reform Commission to look at how non-disclosure might influence consent

‘Should society criminalise intimate relations between people in their mid–teens?’
November 15, 2019

US: 34-year-old man arrested in Mississippi and charged with alleged HIV exposure

In the news
October 28, 2019

Mexico: Law amended in Jalisco to allow people with HIV to marry as long letters confirming awareness of HIV status and couple’s attendance to training on risks are produced

People with HIV can now get married in Jalisco
October 25, 2019

Ukraine: The Ukrainian Helsinki Human Rights Union raises awareness on the need to decriminalise HIV-status

Valeria Rachynska: “We must finally stop the witch–hunting and decriminalize HIV–status”
October 24, 2019

US: Sex worker arrested in undercover operation and facing charges of HIV exposure in Georgia

Police: Sex worker didn’t disclose she was HIV status
December 5, 2019

US: Man arrested and charged in Oklahoma for alleged HIV non-disclosure and transmission

Man arrested, accused of knowingly spreading HIV to two people
December 5, 2019

Tajikistan: Criminal proceedings could be instigated against 2 women in the future if sexual partners develop HIV

Two women may have infected dozens of men in Khatlon with HIV, says Khatlon governor
November 30, 2019

[Update]Russia: Prosecutor approves charges against senior nurse in case of negligence leading to HIV transmissions in Budennovsk hospital

Court investigate to determinate responsibility for the infection of five patients with HIV in hospital in Budennovsk
November 29, 2019

US: 40-year-old Tennessee man charged with alleged HIV exposure

Nashville man indicted on HIV exposure charge
November 26, 2019

US: 42-year-old man charged in Wisconsin for alleged HIV exposure and transmission

HIV–positive man charged after sex with 6 women
November 24, 2019

India: Woman lodges police complaint against medical staff of blood bank after contracting HIV during transfusion

Pregnant woman contracts HIV after blood transfusion in Tamil Nadu
November 23, 2019

[Update]France: Court of appeal increases sentence of 63-year-old man to 4 years for alleged HIV transmission

Perpignan: sentence increased to 4 years for having transmitted HIV to his partner
November 23, 2019

[update]US: Previously convicted ex-police officer facing five felony charges for alleged HIV non-disclosure is heading to trial

Trial to start for ex–cop accused of not telling sexual partners he has HIV
November 20, 2019

[Update]France: 47-year-old man sentenced to 4 years in jail for alleged HIV transmission and non-disclosure

Un Loirétain accusé d’avoir délibérément transmis le virus du sida à son épouse
November 20, 2019
View more >

Sign up for the HIV Justice newsletter

Sign up for regular updates

For more information, please see our Privacy policy

 
Privacy and Cookies Policy | Contact Us

We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. By continuing to use our site, you are agreeing to our use of cookies. You can change your cookie settings at any time if you want. Find out more in our privacy and cookie policy

Accept Close